The Eagle Privy, One Point Below Perfect
This 2025-(P) American Silver Eagle carries the small eagle privy on its front, and PCGS has graded it MS69 First Strike in a flag label holder. It holds 1 troy ounce of .999 fine silver from a privy issue of 500,000, the second bullion Silver Eagle ever to carry a privy mark. MS69 is one point below the top of PCGS’s scale, and for most collectors that point is the whole question.
What Separates MS69 From MS70
PCGS defines MS70 as a coin with no imperfections under high magnification. Its definition of MS69 is a coin whose imperfections, such as hairlines, are virtually undetectable under magnification. In other words, both grades describe a coin that looks flawless in hand. The difference shows only under a loupe, and only to a trained eye.
If you want the Eagle Privy in a high certified grade without paying for the top one, MS69 gets you a coin that looks flawless in hand. Compare it with our MS70 listing and decide whether that last point is worth it to you.
The Privy and the Label
The privy is a tiny eagle in flight on the front. It sits to the right of Liberty, just above IN GOD WE TRUST. The rest of the front is Weinman’s Walking Liberty, and the back carries Emily Damstra’s landing eagle. The label shows the US flag and FIRSTSTRIKE across the top, then 2025-(P), PCGS MS69, Silver Eagle with Eagle Privy, and Struck at Philadelphia. The coin itself has no mint mark. The (P) on the label records where it was made.
First Strike, in Plain Terms
PCGS gives the First Strike designation to coins issued in the first 30 days of the Mint’s release. It describes when the coin came out, not how well it was struck. A First Strike MS69 and a plain MS69 are the same coin under different labels.
Keep It in the Holder
The PCGS grade and guarantee belong to the coin in its holder as PCGS sealed it. A coin taken out of its holder, or a holder that has been tampered with, falls outside the guarantee. Store it flat and leave it sealed.
2025-(P) Eagle Privy Silver Eagle PCGS MS69 Specifications
This coin contains 1 troy ounce of .999 fine silver. It measures 40.6 mm across and 2.98 mm thick, with a reeded edge, and has a $1 face value. It is graded Mint State 69 by PCGS with the First Strike designation and a flag label, and it was struck at Philadelphia. It is IRA eligible. Full details are on the Specifications tab above.
2025-(P) Eagle Privy Silver Eagle PCGS MS69 FAQ
What is the difference between MS69 and MS70?
PCGS defines MS70 as no imperfections under high magnification. At MS69, any imperfections are virtually undetectable under magnification. To the naked eye, the two look the same.
Where is the eagle privy?
On the front, just above IN GOD WE TRUST on the right. It is a tiny eagle in flight.
Does First Strike mean the coin was struck first?
No. PCGS uses it for coins issued in the first 30 days of the Mint’s release. It is about timing.
Why does the label say (P) when the coin has no mint mark?
Bullion Silver Eagles are struck without one. The (P) and Struck at Philadelphia on the label record where this coin was made.
Is it IRA eligible?
Yes. It is IRA eligible. Ask your custodian about their rules for graded coins before you buy.
Want the top grade instead? See the 2025-(P) Eagle Privy American Silver Eagle PCGS MS70 First Strike Flag Label.
Add the 2025-(P) Eagle Privy American Silver Eagle PCGS MS69 First Strike Flag Label to your cart.


