A Proof Gold Buffalo, Year Our Choice
This listing is a proof 1 oz American Gold Buffalo, struck at West Point in .9999 fine gold with a $50 face value and the W mint mark, in its original U.S. Mint box with a certificate of authenticity. The year is chosen from the stock we have when your order ships. These coins come to us through the secondary market, so the box may show some wear from handling.
Mintages That Swing by Year
The U.S. Mint has struck the proof Gold Buffalo every year since 2006, and the number made has varied widely. The first year, 2006, saw 246,267 proofs. By 2024 the figure was down to 10,075 coins, and every year since 2012 has stayed under 22,000. A random-year listing means you do not choose where in that range your coin falls. Every year holds the same ounce of gold.
Reading a Proof Buffalo
Both sides come from James Earle Fraser’s 1913 Buffalo nickel. On the proof, the W mint mark sits on the obverse behind the neck of the portrait, and the bullion version carries no mint mark at all. On the reverse, the mound under the bison that read FIVE CENTS on the nickel now reads $50 1 OZ. .9999 FINE GOLD, and IN GOD WE TRUST sits to the left of and below the bison’s head. Proof coins are struck with mirror-like fields behind frosted design elements, which is the clearest way to tell them from the bullion strike.
Packaging Changes With the Year
The Mint has packaged the proof Buffalo differently over the years, and our photo shows three of the styles: a brown leatherette case lined with a printed buffalo, a black case with its outer sleeve, and a wooden case. You receive whichever case your coin’s year was issued in, with its certificate. The packaging cannot be chosen, and on an older coin the case may show scuffs or wear.
Proof American Gold Buffalo Specifications
Each coin contains one troy ounce of .9999 fine gold, measures 32.7 mm across and 2.95 mm thick, and has a reeded edge and a $50 face value. It is struck in proof at the West Point Mint with the W mint mark. Our Specifications tab lists it as IRA eligible. Full current details are on the Specifications tab.
Proof Gold Buffalo FAQ
Can I choose the year?
No. We fill each order from the proof Gold Buffalos in stock, and the date cannot be requested.
How do I find the W mint mark?
Look on the obverse, behind the neck of the portrait. Only the proof carries the W, so its presence is a quick way to tell a proof from a bullion Gold Buffalo.
What packaging will my coin come in?
The original U.S. Mint case and certificate for its year. The Mint has used leatherette, wooden and black cases over the years, and since these coins come through the secondary market, the case may show handling wear.
How many proof Gold Buffalos were made?
It depends on the year. Mintages range from 246,267 in 2006 down to 10,075 in 2024, and every year from 2017 through 2024 came in under 17,000.
Is the proof Gold Buffalo IRA eligible?
Our Specifications tab lists it as IRA eligible, and at .9999 fine it is well above the purity floor for gold. The coin must be held by your IRA’s custodian, and custodians keep their own lists of accepted proofs, so confirm with yours before you buy.
Prefer the bullion strike? See the American Gold Buffalo 1 oz Coin.
A proof ounce of 24 karat American gold, year our choice. Add the Proof 1 oz American Gold Buffalo Coin (Box & COA) to your cart.


Product Reviews
Login to ReviewThere are no reviews yet.